Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Cary Umhau's avatar

I find that I don't know what access I'd be giving that I would later understand better and wish I hadn't.

Ty Nichols's avatar

Dr. Tobin,

Much of this describes my own working week, down to talking into Wispr Flow rather than typing, so it was good to see the whole road laid out plainly enough for someone who has only ever met the blinking cursor. The turn worth carrying out of the piece, though, is the last one, where you send the rest of the complaint to a person and to God.

David's word in that psalm, the complaint he pours out from the cave, is sichi (שִׂיחִי), and the same word turns up in Genesis when Isaac goes out into the field toward evening, where most translations say he went to meditate. The Talmud reads that evening walk as the first afternoon prayer, and to prove the word means prayer it reaches for another psalm, the one written for the afflicted man who is faint and pours out his complaint before the LORD.

So in the rabbis' hearing an untidied complaint was already one of the oldest names for prayer, which is exactly where your closing line sends the reader, without tidying it first.

There is something right about the machine sorting the pile while the man walks out to the field at evening with whatever is left over, and you drew that line for beginners more clearly than anyone I have read.

Ty

3 more comments...

Ready for more?