Discussion about this post

User's avatar
James McLaughlin's avatar

Sean, I agree, and Psalm 139 makes your building point from the inside. "Your eyes have seen my unshaped substance" (139:16). The Hebrew there is golem, and it shows up only that once in the Old Testament. Before there was a face or a voice or a single feeling to report, God was already looking at someone. That runs opposite to the test we're tempted to run on machines, where fluent talk counts as evidence. The child gives no signal at all and is still seen. And the weaving happens in the womb (139:13), from the inside, where nobody is watching for a performance.

Nathan Krupa's avatar

An essential point in all this is what the soull actually is. The soul is the spiritual principal that animates dead matter and causes the difference between a living being and a cadaver. The soul is created immediately by God (CCC 366).

The internal experience of a person comes from the soul, but a living person in a coma who has no interior experience still has a soul. The interior experience is an effect of the soul, not its source, nor is interior experience the source of man's dignity.

AI is a sophisticated mathematical algorithm that just doesn't have a soul. It is not alive. It just does a really good job of making human beings think that it is.

2 more comments...

Ready for more?